Chronicles

To provide a record of the Society's Disputations for members to access and refer to, the Chronicler, Mr. Wesley Hartwell '11, creates detailed summaries known as "Chronicles" describing the orations, debate, and significant themes of each Disputation. The Chronicles for the fall semester of 2007 are signed by the Council members who presided over those sessions.

The Chronicles for academic years 2008-2009 and 2007-2008 are available for download below:

Academic Year 2008-2009:

Spring Semester 2009:

Disputation XX: 01/29/09 -- Resolved: Israel is a legitimate nation
Disputation XXI: 02/05/09 -- Resolved: Liberate humans from gender
Disputation XXII: 02/12/09 -- Resolved: Nation states should devolve more power to international bodies
Disputation XXIII: 02/19/09 -- Resolved: The works of art incite more curiosity than the works of nature
Disputation XXIV: 03/05/09 -- Resolved: It is possible for excessive laughter to yield cultural decline
Disputation XXV: 04/02/09 -- Resolved: Social democracy would strengthen America
Disputation XXVI: 04/09/09 -- Resolved: All consensual sex is moral
Disputation XXVII: 04/16/09 -- Resolved: Humanitarianism corrupts American liberals

Fall Semester 2008:

Disputation XV: 09/11/08 -- Resolved: Too many of us are choosing financial careers
Disputation XVI: 09/18/08 -- Resolved: The War in Iraq is a failure
Disputation XVII: 10/24/08 -- Resolved: Science impoverishes our souls
Disputation XVIII: 11/13/08 -- Resolved: Popular Music Inspires Good
Disputation XIX: 11/20/08 -- Resolved: The quest to save the environment ought to replace religion as the goal to unify culture

Academic Year 2007-2008:

Spring Semester 2008:

Disputation VIII: 01/31/08 -- Resolved: Man must be forced to be free
Disputation IX: 02/14/08 -- Resolved: Violence is always evil
Disputation X: 02/28/08 -- Resolved: Federalism has outlived its usefulness to America
Disputation XI: 03/27/08 -- Resolved: Secularization is bad for America
Disputation XII: 04/10/08 -- Resolved: The 1960s were a disaster
Disputation XIII: 04/17/08 -- Treatises for Guardianship
Disputation XIV: 05/01/08 -- Resolved: Men can be happy without government

Fall Semester 2007:

Disputation I: 9/13/07 -- Which should assume preeminence, justice or greatness?
Disputation II: 9/27/07 -- Are state governments necessary?
Disputation III: 10/11/07 -- Free trade v. fair trade and the consequences of neo-liberalism
Disputation IV: 10/21/07 -- Guest Lecturer Mr. Bruce C. Clark of The Economist
Disputation V: 11/08/07 -- Should the nation-state gradually devolve powers towards international organizations and authorities
Disputation VI: 11/15/07 -- Power in the executive (in America)
Disputation VII: 11/29/07 -- The merits of feminism and gender equality

Member login